I said I’d write about third-party plan review and the approval calendar — the part of your schedule you don’t control.
In Maine, that stopped being an abstract topic this spring. So let’s talk about what happened.
Maine regulates modular buildings under two different sets of rules, and they don’t line up.
One- and two-family modular homes fall under the state’s manufactured housing program — companies are licensed, the work is inspected in the factory, and that’s been the system for years. That program sat under the Manufactured Housing Board at Professional and Financial Regulation until this past July, when it moved to the Maine Office of Community Affairs. The rules didn’t change with the move. The address did.
Buildings with three or more units fall somewhere else entirely: the Maine Uniform Building and Energy Code. MUBEC requires plumbing and electrical systems to be installed by Maine-licensed tradespeople, with an on-site inspection by the local code enforcement officer.
There is no separate industrialized-building track for those larger buildings. That’s the whole problem in one sentence. One- and two-unit modular has a factory pathway. Three-plus-unit modular doesn’t.
For a long time nobody tripped over the difference. Factories built multifamily modules the way factories build modules, local officials accepted the factory inspections, and projects went up without anybody raising a hand.
Then a reviewer in Portland looked at a proposed project and declined to accept the state-approved factory inspection program. They weren’t wrong. They were reading the code.
That’s what makes this worth writing about. There’s no villain here. There’s a gap between two statutes that everybody walked across for years until somebody looked down.
Here’s what the gap has cost Maine so far, as reported by Mainebiz and the Bangor Daily News:
Roughly 300 units in development are in limbo. Five projects totaling 246 units in Portland, Brunswick, and Rockland hit rising costs and schedule problems, and one needed a major restructuring. One developer estimated that the gap adds around $3,000 per module — somewhere between $24,000 and $468,000 depending on the project.
And the Legislature put about $900,000 into MaineHousing’s budget as a temporary patch, to help cover licensed tradespeople on at least five projects already underway. That is $900,000 of housing money going to resolve a licensing mismatch rather than to build anything.
A state working group looking at housing production innovation put the risk about as bluntly as a state report ever does: the current statute could halt the existing multifamily modular pipeline before any broader reform takes effect.
The fix was supposed to be LD 2229, sponsored by Sen. Chip Curry. It would have allowed factory workers to install plumbing and electrical systems under the supervision or inspection of a master plumber or master electrician.
It had broad support and was expected to pass. I traveled to Augusta that day to observe what was supposed to be a slam-dunk bill that would provide an immediate solution. It died in committee without a vote. The other supporters and I left asking What just happened?
I want to be fair about why, because the easy version of this story isn’t the true one. The bill came late in the session without much input from interested parties. At the very last minute, the Maine Association of General Contractors objected that it moved too far too fast and asked to be part of the process. Within moments, a bill that had unanimous support up to that point died on the vine.
Trade licensing is a serious subject, and the instinct not to loosen it casually is a legitimate one. I don’t think the people who slowed this down were acting in bad faith. I think a good fix got written quickly, arrived late, and its sponsors hadn’t done the work ahead of time to bring the trade associations along.
That’s a process failure, not a conspiracy. It’s also a year of housing.
Out-of-state factories shipped roughly 900 modules into Maine last year. If the current reading holds, a factory in Pennsylvania is not going to staff its line with Maine-licensed electricians and plumbers, which means those producers are effectively shut out of Maine multifamily.
KBS is the only large-volume modular factory in this state. On paper, that’s good for us.
When a reporter asked me about it, I called it a double-edged sword, and I meant it. We build on the order of 350 units a year. Maine’s need is considerably larger than that. A rule that hands us demand we cannot physically serve doesn’t produce housing — it produces delay, and then it produces stick-built.
It also doesn’t help us the way people assume, and the reason is worth laying out.
Being the last one standing is not the advantage it sounds like.
Twenty years ago, this corner of Oxford County was a factory housing cluster, and people around here were proud of it. Five manufacturers were building homes within a few miles of each other, most of them strung along Route 26: Keiser Industries in Oxford, Burlington Homes in Oxford, Oxford Homes in Oxford, Waterford Homes in Waterford, and us in South Paris.
In the first quarter of 2005, those five companies employed 588 people between them, with a combined payroll of $30 million. They accounted for 42 percent of the manufacturing jobs in the area.
Today there’s one of us left.
Keiser closed when its out-of-state parent went through bankruptcy, and about 120 people lost their jobs. Burlington Homes shut down and took at least 60 more with it. I can drive past both buildings in ten minutes.
The wider trend is worse than the local one. In the Northeast, single-family homes built as modular, panelized, or pre-cut fell from roughly 17 percent of production in 2004 to about 5 percent by 2023. For multifamily, that share went from around 11 percent in 2000 to effectively zero.
Zero. In the region with some of the oldest housing stock and tightest supply in the country.
And here’s the part that doesn’t show up in anybody’s statistics: the industry around the factories went with them.
A modular plant does not deliver housing by itself. It needs a set crew that knows how to land a module. It needs riggers and crane operators who’ve done this before. It needs button-up carpenters, mate-line finishers, transport companies with the right equipment and the permits to move it, and electricians and plumbers who understand how a factory-built system gets tied together on site.
Those are specialty trades. They exist in proportion to the work available. When Maine had several plants running, there was enough volume to support a bench of crews who did this for a living. As the plants closed, that bench thinned out, and it has not come back.
So when somebody tells me the current rules protect KBS, what I hear is that they protect us inside a shrinking ecosystem. I’d rather have competitors and a deep bench of set crews than no competitors and struggle to find out who can set a building in March.
The same state working group recommended building off-site construction content into community college and CTE trades programs and expanding apprenticeships at off-site employers. That’s the right instinct. It also takes years, and it only works if there’s enough work in this state to justify somebody choosing that career.
We and the Pennsylvania manufacturers would all like to do more multifamily modular work in Maine. We could expand capacity if the statutory question were settled. But nobody adds a production line for a market that might exist next fall. One developer told me he can’t plan projects based on maybe next year. That applies to factories too.
Uncertainty costs us more than competition does. I’d rather compete with a Pennsylvania factory in a market with clear rules than have the field to myself in one where nobody can plan.
This is where the plan review conversation comes back around, because the rest of the country has already worked this out.
The standard approach is accredited third-party inspection of the factory work, with local officials keeping full jurisdiction over what happens on site — foundation, setting, utility connections, final hookups. The factory piece gets inspected by people accredited to inspect factories. The site piece stays with the town. Nobody gives anything up except duplicated effort.
There’s even a written standard for it now. The International Code Council and the Modular Building Institute developed ICC/MBI 1200 and 1205, covering off-site planning, design, fabrication, and assembly, and the inspection and compliance side.
Maine wouldn’t be inventing anything here. We’d be catching up to the rest of the nation— and we’re further behind than most people realize. That state working group found that Maine is the only state in the Northeast that requires a dedicated license to sell and install modular homes, and recommended getting rid of it. It also recommended replacing the professional license requirement for manufacturers with a straightforward state approval letter.
None of that is deregulation for its own sake. It’s matching the oversight to the thing being overseen.
And the licensing concern deserves a real answer rather than a brush-off. The answer isn’t injecting the processes built for site-built construction into the modular ecosystem — that’s how you end up with a Pennsylvania factory being asked to hire Maine-licensed electricians for a building that will be inspected again when it gets here. The answer is documented supervision, accredited inspection agencies, and clear records, with responsibility for the work staying exactly where it is now.
Assume the current rules. Don’t design a three-plus-unit modular project around a statute that might be amended. Price it the way it is today.
Talk to your code enforcement officer and the state early on. Find out how your specific town is handling it while changing course is still cheap. The projects that got hurt were the ones that found out late.
Ask MaineHousing about the interim funding if your project is one of the ones already underway.
Put the licensed-labor cost in the pro forma. Three thousand dollars a module is a real number. Carrying it and not needing it is a much better outcome than the reverse.
There are several efforts under way to close the gap between single-family and multifamily modular, and the timing matters more than most people realize.
The Maine Office of Community Affairs was directed by the Legislature to take a hard look at the Manufactured Housing Act. MOCA is holding public webinars and stakeholder meetings on potential legislative proposals, and is working alongside a Building Codes and Manufactured Housing study being conducted by the International Code Council. Its recommendations are due to the Legislature by January 1 of next year.
I expect MOCA to deliver on time. That’s not my concern.
My concern is everything that comes after, because a recommendation is not relief. A recommendation has to be turned into a bill. The bill has to be drafted, and then negotiated — and we just watched what happens when that negotiation doesn’t happen early enough. Then it has to be voted out of committee and passed. Then the agencies have to write rules to implement it. Then the rules have to actually take effect.
Every one of those steps has its own calendar, and most of them only run when the Legislature is in session. Add them up, and you are not talking about days or weeks. You are talking about months and years before any of this produces a building that wouldn’t otherwise have been built.
LD 2229 may also come back in the 2027 session. If it passes, it likely wouldn’t take effect until the fall unless it moves as emergency legislation. That’s another year on top of the one we just spent.
Which is exactly why the window that matters is open right now — while the recommendations are still being written, not after they’re filed.
Maine has a housing shortage and a gap in its statutes, and right now the gap is winning.
If you build here — developer, GC, architect, lender — the housing committee and MOCA should hear from you before the session starts, not after a bill is drafted and everyone is reacting to it. That was the problem the first time. It doesn’t have to be the problem again.
I’ll be saying so myself, and I’d rather not be the only one.
Next week: back to the plant. What a production schedule actually looks like, and why your slot is worth more than your price.
— Thatcher